It generally applauds the decision, which had found the united states responsible for breaches of art. Comments on the icjs judgment in the lagrand case christian j. One case was that of lagrand, a german citizen held on death row in the united states defendant. This search engine searches webpages only and displays results in order of relevancy. In the lagrand case, the united states found themselves for the second time within three years before the international court of justice dealing with the death penalty imposed on foreign nationals in the united states. Recognizing guarantees and assurances of nonrepetition.
While the most important feature of the judgment given by the international court of justice in the lagrand case is probably the conclusion that provisional measures indicated by the court are binding. Text of icj judgment in the case of kulbhushan jadhav. Case law of the icj in investment arbitration icsid. International court of justice, case of the monetary gold removed from rome in 1943, preliminary question, judgment of 15 june 1954, i.
The wrongfulness of an act of a state not in consonance with an international obligation is precluded by the distress of the author state if there exists a situation of extreme peril in which the organ of. Critical analysis on the ineffectiveness of the icj in the. The lagrand case was a legal action heard before the international court of justice icj which concerned the vienna convention on consular relations. Provisional measures of the international court of justice. Beyond issues of consular law proper, it analyses the courts crucial holding that interim orders under art 41 of the icj statute can impose binding legal obligations on litigants. Germany alleges irreparable damage as a consequence of walter lagrands execution. Article 41 of the icj statute is the expression of an inherent power of international arbitral tribunals and judicial bodies. Lagrand case icj pdf on june 27, the icj, rejecting all of the united states arguments, ruled in favor of germany.
Final judgement of the international court of justice in the lagrand case germany v. There have been few cases emanating from the middle east at the international court of justice icj. Separate opinion of judge nagendra singh english french bilingual. Not only did the icj state, for the first time in the history of its existence, the binding nature of provisional measures issued under art. Lagrand and the law of state responsibility christian j. International court of justice icj published on by oxford university press. United states of america, which deals with many complex issues of international law. The background to this case, involving walter lagrand, whose name is used by the. Notes on the international court of justice part 6the. United states of america summary of the judgment of 27 june 2001. The lagrand case before the international court of justice, german yearbook of international law 42 1999, 192. With the exception of treaties, international law suffers from ambiguousness and lack of clarity, and it is more so in the case of the role of the icj. Acts and documents relating to judgments and advisory opinions given by the court pleadings, oral arguments and documents.
The court decides cases submitted to it by states and gives advisory opinions on legal questions at the request of international organizations authorized to request such opinions. Tamst looking back at the lagrandjudgment some time after the decision has been rendered, one cannot help but wonder that a dispute of such limited scope should have prompted the international court of justice icj to address. Role of the icj in developing and evolving international. Between 1998 and 2004, the international court of justice icj heard three separate cases all relating to the rights and treatments of aliens on death row in the united states. World court rules against the united states in lagrand case. Pdf a content analysis of the judgment of the icj in the.
Bishop, the unenforceable rights to consular notification and access in the united states. A content analysis of the judgment of the icj in the lagrand case. Yet even in time of war, the convention relative to the laying of automatic submarine contact mines of october 18, 1907 the hague convention no. Tams the international court of justice, in a landmark ruling in the lagrand case,1 held that interim orders under article 41 of its statute impose binding legal obligations upon the parties to the. International court of justice lagrand case germany. Brothers under the vienna convention on consular relations, 200116 june 27, 2001 hereinafter icj press release. Preceding unsigned comment added by suddensam 57 talk contribs 06. Due process and the right to life in the context of the. International court of justice,angloiranian oil co. The icj has both in lagrand and in avena avoided any decision on this point, despite a request to this effect by germany and mexico respectively. Lagrand case the icj had not previously been required to adjudicate, and which has been a source of considerable controversy among commentators. Karl lagrand has been already executed when berlin filed suit against washington. On 2 march 1999, the federal republic of germany filed in the registry of the court an application instituting proceedings against the. The international court of justice and human rights.
Aug 02, 2019 lagrand case icj pdf on june 27, the icj, rejecting all of the united states arguments, ruled in favor of germany. The lagrand case was typical of a nation trying to save the lives of two of its citizens, but the us actions were obvious and predictable under us law. Of course, in accordance with the unfortunate habit of jurisprudential accumulation, they mention the lagrand case and the award in pey casado and add a reference to each new precedent following the same approach, the solution being now presented as part of positive law, but without even bothering to refer to article 47 of the convention. On june 27, 2001, the international court of justice the world court issued its judgment on the merits of the lagrand case germany v. Focus in individual rights in icj proceedings due to jurisdictional constraints. Focus in individual rights in icjproceedings due to jurisdictional constraints. Collection of advisory opinions 19231930 series ab. In the present case, india seeks to found the jurisdiction of the court on article 36, paragraph 1, of the statute of the court and on article i of the optional protocol concerning the compulsory settlement of disputes, which accompanies the vienna convention on consular relations hereinafter the optional protocoland the vienna. Diplomatic protection before the icj and national courts. Thus, the case of the lagrands would have been thoroughly investigated. Statute of the international court of justice, article 60. This note assesses the courts landmakr ruling in the lagrand case. Admission of a state to the united nations, advisory opinion, i. Tams the international court of justice, in a landmark ruling in the lagrand case,1 held that interim orders under article 41 of its statute impose binding legal obligations upon the parties to the dispute.
Tams, the right to consular assistance under international law. This use provides some additional comfort to the interpreter of a treaty provision that the interpretation reached through an exercise under article 31 is not negatively affected by the. The court considers that there is an obligation on the united states government, in the terms of article 1 of the geneva conventions, to respect the conventions and even to ensure respect for them in all circumstances, since such an obligation does not derive only from the conventions themselves, but from the general. The international court of justice divined a fourth use of travaux preparatoiresto prove the nonpreclusion of an interpretationin the lagrand case. Implementation of lagrand and avena in germany and the. The international court of justice reasserts its full commitment to the support of both. Drawing analogy in international law, the international court of justice icj is a principal organ of the united nations, which performs the functions of a judicial body at international plane.
It can be used to search for general information on the court. Breached obligation highlighting the fourteentoone holding of the icj in the lagrand case that the united states. This case raises important questions concerning the relation between, on the one hand, the domestic law of the united states, and, on the other, decisions of the international court of justice interpreting the convention. A more drastic instance of producing an irreversible harm can hardly be imagined. Icj denies belgiums request for provisional measures in the prosecute or extradite case written by joanna harrington joanna harrington is an associate professor with the faculty of law at the university of alberta in canada, where she teaches constitutional law, international law, and international criminal law. The international commission of jurists icj is composed of 60 eminent judges and lawyers from. Separate opinion of judge ruda english french bilingual. International court of justice, nottebohm case second phase, judgment of 6 april 1955, i. Jul 30, 2010 article 41 of the icj statute is the expression of an inherent power of international arbitral tribunals and judicial bodies. Against the law of nations on 3 march 1999, german national walter lagrand was executed in the arizona gas chamber, in open defiance of an order by the international court of justice icj requiring a. International court of justice, consular law, vienna convention on consular relations, lagrand, interim measures, provisional measures, icj statute, death. Referring to the gulf states and excluding iran, the only other contentious case filed at the icj has been qatar v bahrain in relation to maritime boundaries in 2001. On this occasion, germany sued on behalf of two german nationals sentenced to death in arizona. Interim measures of protection for rights under the vienna.
Mar 03, 2008 the icj ruled in favor of germanys lagrand suit on june 26th, 2001, more than two years after the brothers had been put to death. Quite apart from this controversial conclusion, the. In the case, the icj found that its own temporary court orders were legally binding and that the rights contained in the convention could not be denied by the application of domestic legal procedures. Walter lagrand and his brother, german nationals living in the united states, were arrested in arizona in 1982 on suspicion of armed robbery and murder. He has authored several books with his most recent book entitled human rights in. The international court of justice icj has rendered a decision. Diplomatic protection and the lagrand case leiden journal. On 27 june 2001, the international court of justice rendered its final decision in the case of lagrand germany v. The international court of justice and human rights john r. More than three years after the international court of justice icj handed down its decision in the avena case,1 and eight years after germany and the united states first clashed before the court in lagrand,2 the implementation of the vienna convention on consular relations vccr, specifically its article 363 dealing with a foreign nationals right to be informed of his right.
Court has jurisdiction to decide a case, it also has jurisdiction to. More than half its cases have involved disputes over land frontiers and maritime boundaries. History of the proceedings and submissions of the parties paras. It was the first time that a country won a case against the united states on this matter. Compliance with icj provisional measure and the meaning of. To search the full text of case related pdf documents published on this website e. However, a few types of cases have provided much of its work. The court has noted above paragraph 77 in fine that the united states did not issue any warning or notification of the presence of the mines which had been laid in or near the ports of nicaragua. Provisional measures of the international court of justice in. In 1999, a second icj case was filed against the us, resulting in the icjs ruling in the lagrand case germany v united states of america judgment. Icj denies belgiums request for provisional measures in the. Walter lagrand and his brother, german nationals living in the united states, were arrested in arizona in. Collection of judgments, orders and advisory opinions from 1931 series c.
Collection of judgments, orders and advisory opinions from 1931. In the lagrand case, the united states had disregarded the icj order of provisional measures to stay the execution of the brothers lagrand and had moved on to execute them. Icj denies belgiums request for provisional measures in. The federal republic of germany began to provide consular assistance to walter and karl. He has also acted as counsel for the united states of america before the international court of justice in the lagrand case germany vs. Much too late, germany opened a legal case against the united states on walter lagrands behalf at the international court of justice icj in the hague, netherlands. Icj denies belgiums request for provisional measures in the prosecute or extradite case written by joanna harrington joanna harrington is an associate professor with the faculty of law at the university of alberta in canada, where she teaches constitutional law, international law. However, the recent case between qatar and the united arab emirates uae is worth keeping. World court rules against the united states in lagrand. One had just been executed, and the other faced imminent execution. Dissenting opinion of judge oda tion federal republic of. While the most important feature of the judgment given by the international court of justice in the lagrand case is probably the conclusion that provisional measures indicated by the court are binding, the decision is not without significance in the field of diplomatic protection. The wrongfulness of an act of a state not in consonance with an international obligation is precluded by the distress of the author state if there exists a situation of extreme peril in which the organ of the state has, at that particular moment, no means. International court of justice icj the icj is the principal judicial organ of the united nations.
1160 288 1289 333 952 1614 1284 775 384 1139 1220 630 168 513 597 96 558 1169 1305 1326 21 271 1033 15 935 1555 1558 143 910 7 344 1290 599 1499 830 648 1277 1338 1412 1056 639 277